Author Topic: Slr 650 clattering noise under load  (Read 1154 times)

Simons...XBR500

  • Guest
Slr 650 clattering noise under load
« on: July 08, 2017, 12:42:27 PM »
Hi fellas
I've got a slr 650 that's new to me and when it's under load in low rpm I get a rattle or clattering noise until rpms take it away
Quiet at idle hot or cold
Any adeas ?

iansoady

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 1827
Re: Slr 650 clattering noise under load
« Reply #1 on: July 08, 2017, 01:02:29 PM »
There's quite a lot of backlash in the transmission and they can be quite lumpy at low revs. How low are we talking?

I tried to ride mine like a G80 and it didn't like it.......
Ian.
1964 Norton Electra
1969 BSA-Suzuki
1948 BSA C11

themoudie

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 4755
Re: Slr 650 clattering noise under load
« Reply #2 on: July 08, 2017, 04:36:45 PM »
Aye Simons...XBR500,

From your description, I would tend to agree with Ian's diagnosis, "Give it some revs!".  Over-square Japanese singles don't like being 'lugged' in high gears and will make horrible rattling noises that can lead to broken gearboxes and a knocking big-end!  :(  Long stroke singles e.g. Norton, BSA, AJS/Matchless and Arial will "thump" quite happily in a high gear, with a touch of retarded ignition and a slight throttle; they also often have a ruddy great big spring shock absorber on the drive side end of the crankshaft to absorb some of this torque reaction and smooth out the thumps!  ;)  As well as a rubber shock absorber in the rear hub.  ;)

If as your 'handle' suggests that you are already familiar with Japanese singles, then maybe the alternator rotor is starting to chatter on the crankshaft taper due to the 'lugging' and or a fretted woodruff key and an insufficiently torqued rotor nut.

Usually, these motors require 2,000rpm to get them off the mark without stalling and to be doing at least 55 - 60mph afore selecting 5th gear, unlees you have altered the sprockets to provide alternative gearing.

I hope this helps and you can get to enjoy the bike, rather than worry about it.

My regards, Bill

timbo

  • Posts: 2920
Re: Slr 650 clattering noise under load
« Reply #3 on: July 08, 2017, 10:04:28 PM »
Hi Simon. I'm no expert, but these SLRs/Vigors/Dommies don't like to be below three and a half thousand revs, in my experience. Hope it is something as simple as this  ;)
Namaste

Simons...XBR500

  • Guest
Re: Slr 650 clattering noise under load
« Reply #4 on: July 09, 2017, 08:57:31 PM »
Aye Simons...XBR500,

From your description, I would tend to agree with Ian's diagnosis, "Give it some revs!".  Over-square Japanese singles don't like being 'lugged' in high gears and will make horrible rattling noises that can lead to broken gearboxes and a knocking big-end!  :(  Long stroke singles e.g. Norton, BSA, AJS/Matchless and Arial will "thump" quite happily in a high gear, with a touch of retarded ignition and a slight throttle; they also often have a ruddy great big spring shock absorber on the drive side end of the crankshaft to absorb some of this torque reaction and smooth out the thumps!  ;)  As well as a rubber shock absorber in the rear hub.  ;)
Hi bill
It does help thanks very much for the info
The bike is new to me so just learning
Cheers 👍
If as your 'handle' suggests that you are already familiar with Japanese singles, then maybe the alternator rotor is starting to chatter on the crankshaft taper due to the 'lugging' and or a fretted woodruff key and an insufficiently torqued rotor nut.

Usually, these motors require 2,000rpm to get them off the mark without stalling and to be doing at least 55 - 60mph afore selecting 5th gear, unlees you have altered the sprockets to provide alternative gearing.

I hope this helps and you can get to enjoy the bike, rather than worry about it.

My regards, Bill

Simons...XBR500

  • Guest
Re: Slr 650 clattering noise under load
« Reply #5 on: July 09, 2017, 09:01:27 PM »
There's quite a lot of backlash in the transmission and they can be quite lumpy at low revs. How low are we talking?

I tried to ride mine like a G80 and it didn't like it....... not sure exactly as no rev counter but best way I can put it is it seems very sensitive to being the n right gear I thought these motors had lots of torque to pull

Simons...XBR500

  • Guest
Re: Slr 650 clattering noise under load
« Reply #6 on: July 09, 2017, 09:02:32 PM »
Hi Simon. I'm no expert, but these SLRs/Vigors/Dommies don't like to be below three and a half thousand revs, in my experience. Hope it is something as simple as this  ;)
thanks mate so do I 👍

Simons...XBR500

  • Guest
Re: Slr 650 clattering noise under load
« Reply #7 on: July 09, 2017, 09:15:53 PM »
Aye Simons...XBR500,

From your description, I would tend to agree with Ian's diagnosis, "Give it some revs!".  Over-square Japanese singles don't like being 'lugged' in high gears and will make horrible rattling noises that can lead to broken gearboxes and a knocking big-end!  :(  Long stroke singles e.g. Norton, BSA, AJS/Matchless and Arial will "thump" quite happily in a high gear, with a touch of retarded ignition and a slight throttle; they also often have a ruddy great big spring shock absorber on the drive side end of the crankshaft to absorb some of this torque reaction and smooth out the thumps!  ;)  As well as a rubber shock absorber in the rear hub.  ;)
Yes this helps a lot thanks for the info 💪
If as your 'handle' suggests that you are already familiar with Japanese singles, then maybe the alternator rotor is starting to chatter on the crankshaft taper due to the 'lugging' and or a fretted woodruff key and an insufficiently torqued rotor nut.

Usually, these motors require 2,000rpm to get them off the mark without stalling and to be doing at least 55 - 60mph afore selecting 5th gear, unlees you have altered the sprockets to provide alternative gearing.

I hope this helps and you can get to enjoy the bike, rather than worry about it.

My regards, Bill

welland99

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 127
Re: Slr 650 clattering noise under load
« Reply #8 on: July 09, 2017, 11:26:04 PM »
Simon,
Wouldn't be a slack drive chain, would it?  Have you checked the chain tension?

Simons...XBR500

  • Guest
Re: Slr 650 clattering noise under load
« Reply #9 on: July 10, 2017, 07:03:48 AM »
Simon,
Wouldn't be a slack drive chain, would it?  Have you checked the chain tension?
it has 20 mm slack !

themoudie

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 4755
Re: Slr 650 clattering noise under load
« Reply #10 on: July 10, 2017, 08:20:27 AM »
Aye Simon,

15mm - 20mm slack with your full weight sitting on the bike. Be aware that the chain may have lengths which appear tighter or slacker than others and you need to check the tension on a tighter section if you have one. If the chain has become very stiff or slack then consider a new chain and sprockets. I have a measure of allowable wear/stretch for a drive chain from a Yamaha SRX manual, but this might cause unjustifide alarm!  :o  If your sprockets are looking hooked, this is another indication of potential problems.

Finally, if you enter "chain" into the search window in the top right of the 'Bike Problems/Questions' forum window, you will select 7 pages of messages about chain problems and there rectification discussed on this forum down the years and this could be of help.

My regards, Bill

Simons...XBR500

  • Guest
Re: Slr 650 clattering noise under load
« Reply #11 on: July 10, 2017, 06:19:58 PM »
Aye Simon,

15mm - 20mm slack with your full weight sitting on the bike. Be aware that the chain may have lengths which appear tighter or slacker than others and you need to check the tension on a tighter section if you have one. If the chain has become very stiff or slack then consider a new chain and sprockets. I have a measure of allowable wear/stretch for a drive chain from a Yamaha SRX manual, but this might cause unjustifide alarm!  :o  If your sprockets are looking hooked, this is another indication of potential problems.

Finally, if you enter "chain" into the search window in the top right of the 'Bike Problems/Questions' forum window, you will select 7 pages of messages about chain problems and there rectification discussed on this forum down the years and this could be of help.

My regards, Bil
thanks again bill I think I'm going to put a 15t front sprocket on it anyway so motorway speeds a little calmer so will change the lot

themoudie

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 4755
Re: Slr 650 clattering noise under load
« Reply #12 on: July 10, 2017, 10:24:39 PM »
Aye Simon,

Be aware that this change of sprocket size is likely to alter (increase) the number of links in the chain you require. Be careful when purchasing a 'standard' chain for your model of bike, as this may not be long enough to accomodate your increase in size of the gearbox sprocket. If it isn't clear in the parts lists what is being offered and what might be required, enquire before placing your order and if no satisfactory answer is forthcoming, it might be prudent to take your custom elsewhere.

My regards, Bill

iansoady

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 1827
Re: Slr 650 clattering noise under load
« Reply #13 on: July 11, 2017, 09:32:04 AM »
It may also increase the hammering effect as the engine will be turning slower for the same road speed.

I must admit I found mine pretty exhausting at "motorway" speeds and felt 65 was about the maximum for any length of time. But then I'm old and decrepit.
Ian.
1964 Norton Electra
1969 BSA-Suzuki
1948 BSA C11

CrazyFrog

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 1421
Re: Slr 650 clattering noise under load
« Reply #14 on: July 11, 2017, 10:47:26 AM »
I loved mine, no where near as 'revvy' as the F650 but it was the stupidly small tank that drove me mad in the end...
2023 Honda CMC500